Welcome to Papa Everett's Pizza
Papa Everett's Pizza is a charming gem located in Clear Lake, Iowa, at 910 US-18 E. Renowned for its welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, this family-run eatery serves up delicious pizzas that satisfy both locals and visitors. Diners rave about the fresh toppings and flavorful sauces, with standout options like the sausage and mushroom pizza praised for its generous ingredients and tasty crust. The inviting ambiance makes it an enjoyable spot for families, where kids can marvel at the pizza-making process. Don't forget to try the delightful cinnamon sticks for a sweet finish. Overall, Papa Everett's delivers a hearty and satisfying dining experience.
-
910 US-18 E, Clear Lake, IA 50428, United States Hotline: +1 641-357-4040
Welcome to Papa Everett's Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Clear Lake, Iowa. Located at 910 US-18 E, this cozy eatery is not just a place to satisfy your pizza cravings, but it offers a delightful experience that embodies the charm of a local favorite. With a phone number that rings in eager customers at +1 641-357-4040, Papa Everett's is quickly becoming a must-visit for pizza lovers and families alike.
As you step into this quaint pizzeria, you’re greeted with the aromatic scent of freshly baked pizza and a warm smile from the friendly staff. Reviews from patrons like Tristan Rethman highlight the inviting atmosphere, where the staff is always ready to chat, making you feel right at home. The pizzas are praised not just for their great taste but also for the freshness of the toppings and a perfectly blended sauce that keeps you coming back for more. Although some may wish for a thicker crust, it is clear that the ingredients take center stage here!
Another customer, Prickles Hoggington, was particularly impressed with the cleanliness of the establishment, stating, “The eating area, kitchen, and bathrooms were all immaculate." This attention to detail enhances your dining experience, ensuring that you feel comfortable as you enjoy your meal. Families rave about watching the talented staff toss the dough, making every visit a memorable one for kids and adults alike.
The menu offers a variety of options, from classic cheese pizzas to unique combinations like hamburger pizza, and you can indulge in delightful sides like their cinnamon sticks, which have become a favorite among young diners. Customers like Pam Masters appreciated the flexibility of ordering options, and the delivery service is not just efficient but also friendly, as noted by many during their interactions with the staff.
In addition to pizzas, the pasta dishes are also well-received. Pam noted the delicious spaghetti topped with melted cheese, proving that Papa Everett’s doesn’t just specialize in pizza but also offers hearty Italian fare perfect for sharing.
For all those traveling through Clear Lake or simply looking for a new pizza spot, Papa Everett's Pizza promises not only delicious food but also a wonderful sense of community. With its welcoming ambiance, friendly service, and mouthwatering menu, this pizzeria has secured a special place in the hearts of its visitors. Whether you're dining in or taking out, make sure to stop by and experience the delightful offerings of this local treasure!
Great little local place. Staff are nice and talkative if you want to chat. The pizza was great! Toppings were fresh, the sauce was a good blend. I only wish the crust was a bit thicker. I didn't mind the disposable cups, utensils, and plates, most people carry out anyways.
Very nice place to visit. It is small but very clean and the lady was so nice. The pizza tastes great! We had a cheese pizza and a hamburger pizza and the crust was perfect. The kids loved watching her toss the dough. She was so nice and the overall vibe of the place was great. Get the cinnamon sticks! They were a big hit with the kids and tasted amazing. 10/10 I was impress with how clean this place is. Usually smaller, family run places can be grimey, but the eating area, kitchen, and bathrooms were all immaculate. And it smells nice in there. Overall, very impressed.
We ordered delivery , I seen no online ordering so called restaurant. The person on phone was extremely awesome and even though they sounded so busy, they took the time to answer all my questions. I ended up ordering a 12 inch sausage and mushroom pizza and a order of spaghetti all to share with my bestie on our clear lake vacation. I was asked if I wanted spicy r reg sausage we choose reg Italian. It was pretty good pizza. A pizza the whole family could enjoy meaning not overly spicybut with lots of flavor, and the mushrooms tasted so good and fresh not canned. The crust was not to thin r think but there was option to do double crust. Now the spaghetti is smaller and comes with mini bread sticks. Its very yummy but for my belly if I diden have pizza too , I would of needed 2 of the spaghettis but the flavor made up for it. No parm came with it but that was ok because it had a thick topping of melted cheese. I would order here again.. you know the people who work in these restaurants really make the place.. shout out to the friendly order taker n delivery person.. I was happy with everything
The pizza was really good and they were moving fast to get them done. We ordered the the combo, taco, chicken quesodilla, western. ...
My husband was traveling from out of state they were the only place to deliver to his hotel Gentleman on the phone was an absolute joy to talk to he was patient with me since we didn't know the menu or what their options were my husband's food (a medium half pepperoni half cheese pizza and a large order of cheesy bread) arrived steaming hot and it was absolutely delicious highly recommend anybody who's in the area!!
Wow just wow that is the first time I’ve had pizza that reminds me of New York, the super cheese pizza is unmatched!!!
We found this little joint when we got snowed in on our way to Minnesota for Christmas one year. It is now a regular stop when we are in the area. The food is amazing and the service is always top notch!! It was absolutely a bright spot on a bad travel day and now we recommend it to everyone.
We visited Clear Lake, Iowa and found out that Domino’s and Pizza Hut did not exist. Since the pizza chains do not deliver here, we choose Papa Everett’s Pizza. Good prices and very delicious, generous ingredients.